Based on 260 reviews
Largo - 6" Medium custom mattress
Dusty R. (Toronto, ON)
Comfortable and soft

I got this mattress for a weirdly sized room and am satisfied! The firmness and size are correct. No complaints

Cocoa - Luxury Firm, custom mattress
Barbara S. (Nashville, TN)


Cape - 6" Medium, custom mattress
Glendele W. (Santa Ana, CA)
Super comfortable mattress

I needed to buy an extra thin mattress, and I am so happy to say this mattress is still extremely comfortable.

Clearwater - Medium, custom mattress
William H. (Indian Trail, NC)
Great workmanship, excellent product.

After reviewing online and submitting questions via email, we decided to order our custom mattress with Custom Mattress Makers. Once the order was submitted, we were notified it was in process, and within 7 days it was shipped to us. Couldn’t be happier with the quality and comfort as well it fitting perfectly in the space we had built. Thank you all so very much for such an impressive mattress! We won’t hesitate to recommend your products and services to others.

Clearwater - Medium, custom mattress
Sally W. (Portsmouth, VA)

Thank you so much for a comfortable, affordable mattress that fits my 100 year old bed perfectly. You are terrific. I will certainly be getting mattresses for my other beds from you as well. It was very easy to install. Lovely.

Cocoa - Luxury Plush, custom mattress
jacqueline p. (Long Valley, NJ)
Cocoa - Luxury Plush Qeen 10" Depth

I contacted Custom Mattress after stumbling upon them on the internet. At the time I had 2 in the box mattresses that I was trialing and not entirely sure I wanted to keep either and the trial period was approaching. I spoke with Jake at CM and went away from that conversation with a good feeling about the company overall, and the service I was going to get if I were to pursue making a mattress purchase through them. As it ended up, I took the plunge yet again and with Jake's guidance I made the purchase. My decision was based on the information on line and the information I was given speaking with Jake. My new mattress arrived in about 2 weeks, I slept on it the first night. The mattress I believe is true to all information provided, I am 2-3 weeks in and so far so good. I feel relieved the search is over and I will have a quality product for many years to come. I also know if for any reason that changes, that CM stands behind their product and best in class Customer Service, that they will help me out if ever needed. Since I am a petite, female, single sleeper,that sleeps hot, the key points I was looking for was a mattress that had some feeling of conforming to areas such as hips, shoulders, and to feel like the fabric and breathability of the mattress was not going to feel clammy or hot. So far those boxes are checked as meeting my expectations. I again thank Jake for all his assistance!

Largo - 8" Medium Firm custom mattress
Matthew K. (Charlotte, NC)
Awesome mattress

Awesome service awesome mattress awesome business❤️

Daytona - Firm, custom mattress
Daniel J. (Battle Ground, WA)
New bed, new comfort.

In the process of updating our 2006 Fleetwood Discovery we removed to hide a bed couch, which was not very useable for us. I built a bed frame with a platform lift to access storage space under the bed. I ordered a custom size Daytona firm mattress. It arrived the day I finished the bed frame. It is firm and very comfortable. We now have a daybed that serves as a couch and a comfortable bed. We are very pleased.

Cape - 6" Medium, custom mattress
Tyler H. (Denver, CO)
Perfect for Hotshot Trucking!

Made sleeping in the cramped pickup so much better! Worth every penny!

Cocoa - Luxury Medium custom mattress

Cocoa - Luxury Plush, custom mattress
Duane C. (Riverside, CA)

I have owned every major brand of mattress there is. My CMM mattress is PERFECT!! I love it! KEEP IT UP!!!


We are satisfied with our new mattres. Product came in 2 weeks as expected. The package was compact air sealed,as it is the current standard for shipping mattresses. This makes it easy to move it to the beadroom. Althoug it is heavy.
One thing that is different from conventional mattresses is the indiviual coils support system. It does a good job supporting the body. And it allows the mattres to bend, which I guess is good if you have those adjustable beds. It does feel different when you tuck the sheets under, I was used to the mattres being a little more rigid. But I guess it won't be a problem and it will hold the sheets or blankets tucked in place.
In terms of room for improvement, the fabric on the back (under) could be of better quality. Mine ripped a little when putting the mattres on the bed as it landed on one corner of the bed, which wasn't sharp, just a wood corner. Not a biggie since I'll never going to see it but still, a stronger back side fabric would be better.

Cocoa Plush King

Custom Mattress Makers is a great company that makes an excellent mattress matched with attentive customer service. We were skeptical about getting a king mattress with thousands of coils rolled up and shipped in a comparatively small box but it really can be done! We are sleeping in luxury waking up well rested and with no pain. Thank you!

Cape - 6" Medium, custom mattress
David M. (Hampton, NH)
Custom Cape Mattress

My buying experience on-line was superior. All my questions and concerns were answered quickly and precise. Nick, the mattress maker, had so much patience dealing with me. My mattress arrived quickly, and the custom fit was perfect. Can see that care was taken in making my mattress as the workmanship shows. Very comfortable (had it made with firmer foam) and I cannot be a more happier sleeper.

Cape - 6" Medium, custom mattress
Fred K. (Breckenridge, CO)
Custom RV Matress

A perfect fit, good quality, and very comfortable! Thanks!

Cape - 6" Medium, custom mattress
Derek H. (St. Petersburg, FL)

We wanted a comfortable low profile inner spring mattress with notched corners for our historic bedstead. Jake was so very helpful throughout the ordering process. The mattress is beautifully crafted and a perfect fit. It even arrived ahead of schedule!

Great mattress!

We love our new mattress! Arrived early, perfect fit and very comfortable!

Love our new mattress!

It took awhile to get our mattress in but it was well worth the wait! I am very happy with the quality and comfort of the mattress!

Custom sized for motorhome

I'm pleased to have a 33"x78" custom sized hybrid mattress (Cocoa Luxury Firm) in my motorhome to replace the awful, hot, slow-quicksand-like memory foam one. I haven't had the opportunity to actually spend a night on it yet, but I took a "test nap", and I am happy with the comfort level so far. I do wish that there was a firmer option (maybe a dunlop latex layer option instead of the talalay latex). I had a couple of questions before I made my purchase, and was surprised to have my phone call answered by a human (Jake), who was also able to answer my questions! My husband may decide to upgrade his mattress now that he sees the quality of my mattress, so we will probably be back for another one soon! Thank you!

Daytona - Firm, custom mattress
Jennifer (Albemarle, NC)
Spectacular in every way

Seriously - spectacular! Customer service, timeliness, the actual product is perfection and so so so comfortable and supportive. Could not be happier and will now always be getting my mattresses from these guys!

So Far So Good!

We purchased 2 custom twin mattresses for our Class C Sprinter Chasis RV, 72" x 30". They came as promised UPS, we rolled them out on the platforms gave them the instructed 24 hours to settle after shipping then used them last night on our first camping trip since purchase. We both woke up feeling great after all the other trips sleeping on what came with coach which equated to a chaise lounge cushion. More than I was hoping to spend but a good night sleep was well worth it. Now the test will be how well they hold up with time.

Clearwater - Medium, custom mattress
Gail S. (Gloucester, MA)
Clearwater medium

We got the Clearwater mattress and we are thrilled with it. It is a custom size and it fits the space perfectly.
Jake and Nick were great to work with and I highly recommend them and Custom Mattress Makers.

Daytona - Firm, custom mattress
John D. (Odenton, MD)

Easy to unpack and install. Very comfortable and firm.

Daytona - Firm, custom mattress
kacie c. (Rumford, RI)
Love it!

super comfy! Firm but not hard. and love the cooling gel ontop can tell its good quality. Also the customer service was amazing they helped me throughout the whole process !

Daytona, 71" x 82" mattress
iK (Cedar Knolls, NJ)

The mattress is not bad, but I do feel like the springs are a bit more apparent than my last mattress, which had more foam covering them. I feel like I can feel them at times. Maybe it's a thing that I need to get used to since my old mattress was very old. Overall, I am glad I found a custom size mattress within my budget though.