Authentic Customer Reviews

Based on 187 reviews
95%
(178)
4%
(8)
1%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
C
Daytona - Firm Custom Mattress
Chareen T. (Deepwater, NJ)
Ordered this for a semi truck.

We put this mattress in our semi truck. Ordered a custom size which fits perfectly on the murphy bed. Very happy with our purchase. Thank you.

R
Daytona - Firm Custom Mattress
Robert E. (Tonawanda, NY)
Mattress Comfort

The mattress fit perfectly, the sheets are a perfect fit also. The best part of the purchase is a comfortable sleep on an extra firm mattress. Thank you for your expertise.

J
Clearwater - Medium Custom Mattress
Jean-Pierre B. (New York, NY)

Clearwater - Medium Custom Mattress

J
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
JAMES T. (Rockwall, TX)
Waterbed mattress to custom mattress

This is by far the best thing I've done in the last few years. After over 50 years in a waterbed mattress, this Custom Mattress Maker is absolutely perfect for my time of life in my late 70's. Perfect comfort in every way. Great service too!

v
Daytona - Firm Custom Mattress
volodymyr s. (Palm Harbor, FL)
mattress

wonderful mattress, high quality. the guys did everything very quickly and efficiently. if you need a cool mattress for your needs, please do not regret it.

R
Sanibel - Latex Custom Mattress
Rhonda d.K. (Bremerton, WA)
Fantastic

Fits perfectly and feels great!

M
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
Meg W. (Washington, DC)
It’s a winner!

We had trouble finding a company that would make our “Olympic Queen “ mattress. We were impressed with the website and decided to buy. It’s not easy investing in a mattress sight unseen. Good news! We really love our new mattress. The whole transaction went as advertised

R
Sanibel - Latex Custom Mattress
Rebecca C. (Glastonbury, CT)
I’m SO happy I did this!

It’s been at least 25 years since I’ve had a mattress that fits my grandmother’s 4 post bed. It’s probably over 100+ years old. And, this mattress is so comfortable. I’m definitely smiling!

Excellent All Around!

Nick was awesome from the first call to delivery. He helped me figure out the exact measurements and stayed with me thru the entire process. I knew i was going to be out of town.. So he made sure i would be home before shipping so i would be sure to be there to get it. Quality is excellent.. Nick was excellent.. Super satisfied!

J
Clearwater - Medium Custom Mattress
Joan G. (New York, NY)

Clearwater - Medium Custom Mattress

C
Clearwater - Medium Custom Mattress
Caryn P. (Glen Arm, MD)

Great experience! Very communicative to make sure the measurements were correct and to make sure the end product was to my liking. I highly recommend!

T
Cocoa - Plush Latex Custom Mattress
Tracy L. (Edgewood, NM)

Cocoa - Soft Latex Custom Mattress

A
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
A. (West New York, NJ)
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress

This company is fantastic! The mattress is wonderfully comfortable. I feel like I am sleeping literally on a cloud. The lead time was exactly what was estimated on the website. The team was immediately responsive to my email, with top-quality customer service. 'European grand king' is the size I ordered and I am happy to have the exact perfect fit for my bed frame. Highly recommend. Thank you!!

R
Cape - 6 Inch Custom Mattress
Rebecca A. (Philadelphia, PA)
great mattress

wonderful comfort and feel

A
Daytona - Firm Custom Mattress
Anne M. (Queens, NY)
Great service, great quality, great price

After 4 “standard” king size mattresses that ran short from other companies, Custom Mattress Makers was able to make the perfect 76” x 80” mattress for our custom bed. Nick was very helpful and patient, and his team was able to make the size as specified. We were a bit worried about the firmness since we couldn’t test it out in person before purchasing, but the Daytona Firm Custom mattress is perfect. The price was also reasonable. We are very happy with our purchase. It is beautiful in our new home.

s
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
stephanie r. (Orlando, FL)
It come as a bed in a bag but as far from that

It fits perfectly in my antique bed. It is medium firm as I requested. I've slept in it for two weeks and love it

O
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
Orna M. (Bedford, MA)
Very comfortable mattress

We purchased two mattresses. They are for our vacation rental property, so it was important to us to be able to please a large random group of people. With Nick‘s advice, we settled on the Cocoa-Firm Latex mattress. We like a fairly firm bed. This mattress is so comfy on top, not firm at all, but yet it gives the full support we get from our firm mattress. We may like it more than our mattress at home! The shopping experience was very pleasant and easy. The mattress shipped to us in a surprisingly small box and when we opened it and unwrapped the plastic, it bounced right into shape. The size was perfect (it was a custom size). Highly recommend.

C
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
Carol D. (Hackettstown, NJ)

Beautifully made and comfortable. Convenient delivery and setup. Size was more like a regular full instead of the “undersize” measurements we specified.

W
Cape - 6 Inch Custom Mattress
Wendy A. (Longview, TX)
Mattress is Perfect!

Thank you for excellent work. The mattress fit our space exactly as requested. Was such an easy process and finished our custom space off perfectly. Thank you for great service.

V
Daytona - Firm Custom Mattress
Valerie R. (Milford, PA)
Fantastic

I love my new mattress. I will order again from this company. The Customer Service was fantastic. Nick was patient with us and walked us through everything, providing the support we needed to wind up with a very comfortable mattress.

D
Cape - 6 Inch Custom Mattress
Donald H. (Baltimore, MD)
Cape-6 Inch Custom Mattress for a carved Thai bed

The Cape-6 Inch Custom Mattress fits our Thai bed beautifully. While in Thailand three decades ago, we purchased a bed whose mahogany strength and whose unique by-hand carving upon its headboard would suit a princess. Because of its non-western size and dimensions, we have had to improvise over the years on cushioned mattresses. Our Custom Mattress now matches this "royal" bed in size and comfort. We are thankful and celebrate each morning our having found Custom Mattress Makers.

P
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
Paul F. (Essex Fells, NJ)

What a wonderful company to deal with actually spoke with the owner who gave wonderful advise.
I actually like this mattress better than my $20,000 Kluft.
GREAT, EASY, SPEEDY, just a PERFECT EXPERIENCE

r
Cocoa - Plush Latex Custom Mattress
richard h. (Winter Garden, FL)
Cocoa-Soft Latex Mattress

Most comfortable mattress I have ever slept on!!!!

J
Cocoa - Firm Latex Custom Mattress
Juanita H. (Portland, OR)
Love it

Thank you so much for my mattress. I am able to sleep a lot better. It is so comfortable. It is the best mattress I have ever had. Thank you again! And may all have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New year🎄🎄❄️❄️⛄️⛄️🦌🦌😃😃

Worth it's Weight

Outstanding. We are so glad we found Custom Mattress Makers for our daughter's odd-size, antique German bed. She loves her mattress! My personal communications w/ the staff person to answer questions was easy and quite helpful. Many thanks!